When patch 1.04 for Bloodborne was being hinted at , I was ecstatic to see my favourite game of 2015 so far being given careful post-launch support. The game was was a masterpiece of design and atmosphere, but despite everything it got right, there were a few things that needed fixing.

I never would’ve expected however, that the patch would not only fix some problems with the game, but single-handedly sabotage the entire design philosophy of the series. It was shocking and disheartening, and I actually wondered if it was a practical joke.

It isn’t a practical joke, and I am having trouble even coming up with a cohesive explanation to why From Software would do such a thing to their own baby.

Summoning Is Sacred

I must admit that I am tempted to simply post this video and leave it at that, as it perfectly encapsulates one of the main problems with this patch – the ability for any player of any level to summon any player of any level.

If you have played Bloodborne or another Souls game, you’ll know that the games are based on what is essentially a glass floor of balance. They’re so carefully crafted that the way in which you take on foes and bosses is beautifully executed, offering some relief when you can gain a few levels, while always challenging you despite how good you become at the game.

This among many other things that I will discuss later are disregarded when you can simply have your high-leveled friend join your game with a maxed out Ludwig’s Holy Blade and some spells to five-shot any boss you’ll encounter.

Furthermore, the fact that you can summon anyone so long as the boss isn’t killed means that you can literally have someone smack their way through the majority of the game with you, doing literally nothing but following on auto-pilot as they reign down chaos.

While some might think that this only affects those who choose to utilize this feature, there is still an inherent problem with the very idea.

2622877-insta005

 We’re In This Together

 When I say this, I don’t just mean through jolly cooperation, I mean as a community at large. We all play the Souls games and Bloodborne for differing reasons, but we are all privileged enough to feel the intense satisfaction of overcoming our fears, weaknesses, and ignorance to defeat the game’s toughest challenges, and that is an idea I cherish.

 When I’m struggling through a hard area, I can think to myself that there are many other people in the same situation as me. We’re all in this together and we’re all toughing it out to be granted the endless enjoyment of such a unique franchise.

 Except that this all counts for nothing when the game is reduced to what I will call Casualborne. A game where you can steamroll every single hurdle through what is now the equivalent of a ghost writer.

Where is the satisfaction in summoning help in the form of an extremely high leveled player? Where is the sense of achievement you’d earn by completing a nefariously designed area? The truth is that if you utilize this feature, you will experience none of this and it’s a damned shame. It goes against the basic design philosophy of this series: overcome through patience and perseverance.

 As someone who not only supports this series wholeheartedly, but also wishes to preserve the essence of what makes this series such a stand-out in an age of absolutely tepid triple A titles and pre-order culture, I cannot just watch it happen and accept it.

 You should be proud that you are amongst a small group of gamers that enjoy such a masochistic and skill-demanding experience, and you should not let your precious memories of this franchise vanish into nothing but memories of having a friend do everything on your behalf.


bloodborne-gif-2

 We’ve Only Just Begun

 I don’t want to give you the wrong impression that this only impacts the single-player experience, as this is also potentially catastrophic to the online experience, and that is where my true worry comes into play.

Bloodborne, like the games before it, has a unique online feature that allows a player to jump into the single-player world of an unsuspecting victim so that the invader may slaughter him and earn some precious echoes.

 This mechanic is one that has been fully embraced by the community since Demon’s Souls, and it is a mainstay feature in this series. This patch ruins it too.

 Picture this scenario if you will. You as an honest player spend dozens of hours enjoying Bloodborne and learning the mechanics. After a while you decide that you want to go head to head with someone in the form of PVP, but when you ring your Sinister Resonant Bell and find yourself in the world of another, you come to a sad realisation… it’s been set up.

 You join the world of a player your level, and as you go forth weapon in hand, you see that he has a friend (or three) that are not only incredibly high leveled, but possess the advantage of having home field and preparation on their side. You quickly get ambushed in what can only be called a pre-planned ganking scenario, and you find that you are completely helpless to the overwhelming power of these foes.

 That is exactly the scenario you will be seeing more and more of as this patch becomes more and more exploited by a community that thrives on ganking montages and yoloswaggin’ PVP videos.

 I’d be foolish to think that this is the first time players have summoned friends to mess up unsuspecting invaders, but at least before we had fair-game in the form of level and item restrictions… mostly. This is made even worse when you consider how many exploitable bugs Bloodborne had that allowed any player who so chose, to immediately glitch their way to enormously high levels with unlimited currency.

 It’s a big amoeba of small problems that form into one hideous entity that even Miyazaki himself couldn’t have drawn on paper.

 

Bloodborne Werewolves

 Of Pandemic Proportions

 If you were under the impression that these kinds of scenarios would be reserved for only small groups of friends, you’d be sorely mistaken, as even those who hate this patch can still be directly involved in it. I’ll explain how with another hypothetical scenario.

You want to experience the world of cooperation and so you think to yourself “I’ll ring my Small Resonant Bell and help someone out on my favourite boss so that I can have a repeated viewing”. After waiting a brief moment, you find yourself pulled into a world that at first seems normal. When you reach the boss fog however,  you realise that you have a friendly summon who is so powerful that the boss music doesn’t even get to start before the creature is dead and you are on your way out. You, who is a sucker for challenge and likes to experience the grind of slowly whittling away at a boss’s health until he finally collapses cannot enjoy this, because even you are thrust into the new-found community of boss cheesers. Something I don’t believe is far and few between, by the way, especially when you consider how Reddit has been behaving since the patch hit.

It hasn’t even been a single week and the Bloodborne subreddit already has threads and comments popping up with people asking for specifically high-leveled players to help on bosses.

 There are even community-based passwords in place on Facebook, Reddit, and the Bloodborne Wiki that enable you to instantly summon the help of anyone who is also using the password in the community. It’s no longer about finding a summon of equal strength, but now just a waiting game until an obligatory tank comes in and slaughters everything for you.

 The idea that we have entire communities set out to cheese a game that is meant to be legitimately overcome makes my blood boil, but I can’t really do much about it.

06K72fC

 A Little Bird Told Me

Beyond everything I’ve talked about, what is perhaps the most discouraging thing of all is the response to this patch. It has been overwhelmingly positive from what I and some close friends have witnessed.

 It seems that amongst the fans that I have encountered and several articles that have surfaced covering the details of the patch, most people welcome this change, claiming that it’s now a more social experience like they had hoped it’d be.

 What?!

 Since when was a single Souls game about social play? Do you not remember how you couldn’t use any form of party chat on Xbox 360 with the original Dark Souls? Do you not remember how before Dark Souls II’s horrific voice-chat, the only way to communicate in the game would be via gestures? Do you not remember the purposeful design of camaraderie through the conquering of bosses, not through direct interaction? Do you not remember the ‘prepare to die’ slogan the encapsulated the type of experience you’d be in for? Do you not remember how Hawkeye Gough had the only items that could even allow you to directly speak to a player but only by means of a few key phrases? All of this was done deliberately, and this patch again destroys the idea and the design.

 The idea of Dark Souls and especially Bloodborne more than all, is to be absorbed in a world and thrust into scenarios that would make anyone quiver in fear. You are meant to be scared, isolated, alone, confused and lost. These emotions make it much more rewarding when you tackle a difficult stretch, and they would all be irrelevant if this were a directly social experience.

You aren’t thinking about the atmosphere or the labyrinthine design of the castle you’re in, if all you’re doing is teasing your friends while you casually swing your swords with your brains off, steam-rolling even the toughest of foes without blinking an eye.

 It’s almost as if nobody wants to play a Souls-like Souls game any longer. It’s like they want the title of ‘I beat an extremely difficult game’ without actually having to put in any work, and that is discouraging to say the least.

 

 

15 COMMENTS

  1. This is a big PS4 exclusive right now. Sony needs it to be rather accessible, even if Souls games aren’t about accessibility.

  2. It’s a shame, but the franchise that was a once niche is getting bigger, this brings the tendency of making the games more “acessible” so it can catter to a wider crowd. It also probably means that the devs will take less risks from now on, they don’t want risk their sales, the hit the invasion system took in the game and now this is a sign of that, so the games most likely won’t be getting harder from now. Honestly, I don’t have much hope for the quality of the future games.

  3. It never ceases to amaze me how worked up people get about how other people play a game.

    Ganking is probably a legitimate compliant, otherslwise get over yerself

  4. The author is worried about the game becoming pop and destroying everything liked. For me is too much bullshit for a simple change. The game still a master piece, more accessible for newcomers. Which will increase the public and the possibility of a new game. Stop being a whinning bitch.

  5. Just let the people chose their own difficulty. Its like the ring in ds2 where you dont loose humanity.. Use it for easy, dont use it for normal und use the convenant at the beginning for hard. Thats better than give official difficult settings. If they chose to ask a friend.. Fine! You want it Hardcore? Do it alone. But dont ruin the game for others just because you dont like a change which gives people with less time or skill a good time in the game.

  6. Half of this article is false. You don’t summon anyone of any level. You only summon people of any level if they match your password. The gawking scenario is correct, but it hasn’t happened to me more than twice in about 50 invades. So, be careful what you read out there.

  7. Yeah that was a pretty bad article. I have loved all the souls games but honestly in most cases levels dont even give you that much of a benefit because the soft caps so even with a 50 level difference the higher levwl player has deminishing returns on points spent. Not to mention the games always revolved around skill. Im sure someone with a lot of skill will provide plenty of challenge to a higher level player.

  8. I apologize for the community. I stopped playing bloodborne roughly a week after the load screen patch, so I’m not up to date on current fads but I agree with you and your article. I had never heard of this patch, but I’m glad I read about it from you. This is exactly the kind of thing that gets me worked up about this industry. I want to keep this brief, I would like it if we could discuss this more via email (I assume you have access to it since I needed it to comment). My two cents:
    Video Games are an amalgam of all of the fine arts, and should be treated as an art. Making them cater to wider audiences is the same thing as censorship and homogenization in art and music. We wouldn’t ask, or expect a painter to change his work in order to cater to a larger audience, and developers shouldn’t be put in that position either.

  9. I know this is long, so here’s the tl;dr version: It doesn’t matter how other people play. Play the game how you want, and let others play how they want.

    Here’s the full thing:
    I understand the want for challenging games; it’s the reason I play titles like Bloodborne. I want that for myself, but why does the way others play the game matter so much? If someone wants help and wants the game to be easier, who cares? Let them play it that way; it’s their experience with the game. There’s no reason it has to ruin the game for you, you can still play it however you want.

    I get that people don’t want these games to start being dumbed down. I don’t want that either. But the more people there are buying and playing this game, the better it is for everyone in the long run. FROM is clearly not going to make the base experience of their games cake walks; the intense challenge is still there for people who want it. If someone wants it to be easier, though, let it be easier for them. It doesn’t affect your experience with the game unless you choose to play it that way.

    FROM needs to make money, and allowing the game to be more accessible grants them a chance to be more successful. In my experience as a gamer I worked my way up to challenges. I would not have wanted this to be one of my first experiences playing games, but I’m glad it’s here now that I am experienced. I wouldn’t want people getting turned off games in general because they tried this too early on in their gaming lives; it’s not good for the industry, it’s not good for FROM, and it’s not good for us, the people who like these games and want more of them.

    tl;dr version: It doesn’t matter how other people play. Play the game how you want, and let others play how they want.

LEAVE A REPLY